Second Circuit Sides With New York on Non Domiciled CDLs, but Drivers Gain Little
Published November 15, 2026 | Updated November 15, 2026
New York won its money back on Friday. Non domiciled drivers won nothing they can use on Monday.
A unanimous Second Circuit panel agreed with the state that the federal decision to withhold $73,502,543 in highway funds was "arbitrary and capricious," as FreightWaves reported.
That money was about 4% of New York's normal funding. The fight centered on roughly 32,600 non domiciled CDL and permit holders in the state, about 7% of its commercial licenses and permits. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) said New York let licenses outlast the holders' authorized stays in the country.
The court said the rules in force at the time had no such requirement. FMCSA conceded that point, which the court said "should be the end of the matter."
Read the ruling narrowly. It looks backward. New York was punished for breaking a rule that did not exist yet, and the court noted that FMCSA had not shown a single earlier case where it found a state noncompliant on this ground.
The rule that exists today is a different one. FMCSA's final rule took effect on March 16, 2026, and limits new and renewed licenses for foreign domiciled drivers to a short list of employment based visa categories. Work permits alone no longer qualify, Land Line reported. The Second Circuit did not touch that rule. The challenge, Lujan v. FMCSA, was argued in the D.C. Circuit in September, and as of November 15, 2026, no decision has been issued as far as I know.
| State or rule | Where it stands | Source |
|---|---|---|
| New York | Court voided the $73.5 million withholding on November 13, 2026 | FreightWaves |
| Ohio | Program ending, remaining holders downgraded to standard licenses (announced October 23, 2026) | Ohio BMV |
| California | Not issuing or renewing, no restart date given | California DMV |
| Federal rule | In effect since March 16, 2026, D.C. Circuit decision pending as of November 15, 2026 | Federal Register |
States keep moving on their own. Ohio said it will downgrade every remaining holder after already downgrading about 2,000 of the roughly 5,000 it reviewed. California's DMV says it is not currently issuing non domiciled licenses.
The best case for celebrating is that the ruling holds DOT to the rules as they were written at the time when it cuts a state's funding. That matters for states still under review. It does little for a driver holding the license. Winning a funding fight does not give anyone a license back.
My take, and it is only my take: if you hold or hire on a non domiciled CDL, skip the New York headlines and watch the D.C. Circuit. That decision decides whether the current rules stay. Until it lands, check your state DMV notice. If you hire these drivers, keep every expiration date in your driver qualification file.
FMCSA is also tightening CDL rules on other fronts, including CDL school vetting and the end of the paper medical card exemption. This is general information as of November 2026, not legal advice. Confirm your own status with your state DMV or FMCSA.