Truckers Are Being Pulled Off the Road Over What They Can Read, and the Totals Are Public
Trucking News · Analysis · Published November 5, 2026
The Arkansas totals from Operation Highway Shield are public now, and the biggest number in them is the easiest to misread. Officers ran 1,724 inspections in 48 hours and put 393 drivers and vehicles out of service, and counted 183 English language proficiency disqualifications, according to the Arkansas Department of Transportation.
My take: 183 out of 393 is about 47%, and it is tempting to read that as nearly half of drivers failing on language. The releases do not support that.
The language check has two parts, and one of them leaves a lot to the officer. Transport Topics reports that the interview about routine job duties has no standardized scoring, while the road sign test is more objective. John Esparza, president and CEO of the Texas Trucking Association, told the outlet that some carriers have seen drivers pass these checks in Texas and fail them in Arkansas. Totals only help drivers if every agency counts the same way.
Start with the wording. The state release counts drivers and CMVs together in the 393 and calls the 183 disqualifications. The federal release from November 4 lists drivers and vehicles in its table and calls the 183 violations, yet its headline says more than 300 truckers. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said the operation pulled over 300 dangerous drivers, including "183 foreign drivers that couldn't read road signs." None of the documents say how many of the 393 are drivers and how many are trucks, or whether every language violation also produced an out of service order.
| Wave | Out of service | Language count | Share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Florida, March | 176 | 54 | 31% |
| IL, IN, IA, OH, July | 766 | 36 | 5% |
| Arkansas, October | 393 | 183 | 47% |
Source: FMCSA releases. Shares are my own math. DOT words the language count differently by wave: out of service in Florida, violations in July and Arkansas.
The jump from 5% to 47% stands out. It could reflect who was stopped, how officers applied the test, or how the agencies counted. The documents do not say which.
Outside the blitzes, the pace looks steady. DOT says 33,000 drivers have been put out of service since April 2025 for not speaking basic English or reading road signs, up from 26,000 in August. That is about 2,300 a month by my math, close to the 2,000 a month that an American Trucking Associations vice president told Transport Topics.
The case for the crackdown is a fair one. The English rule dates to 1937, Transport Topics notes, but a 2016 guidance memo led to little out of service enforcement for years. I agree that a driver who cannot read a work zone sign is a risk. Critics make a different point. Kendra Cowley, a Laramie resident, told Wyoming Public Media that letting local police run the test hands them "a subjective power to end someone's career on the spot." Both are arguments about the rule. Mine is only about the counting.
Arkansas also reported 74 immigration violations referred for federal immigration enforcement. Separately, DHS says Operation Guardian arrested more than 230 people across 15 states from Oct. 26 to 28, including more than 40 CDL holders. Arkansas was one of the 15, and the releases do not say whether any of these counts overlap.
If you run legal, the prep is simple. Be ready to explain your job in clear English, know the common road signs, and keep your papers current. I covered the paper side in an earlier piece.
Publishing the totals is a start. It would help more if agencies printed drivers and trucks on separate lines and showed the language violations inside the out of service count. Until they do, 47% is just division. More owner operator news is on the Trucking News page.